
Walking into an Apple Store Feels like This ...
Apple Is Winning the Computing Culture War
Of necessity I’ve been a Microsoft user from day one. This sad fact rankles me no end because while I’ve always found Microsoft products to be exceedingly kludgy, most of my business associates have both feet firmly planted in Excel Word World.
Grr.

Grr
When my iPod nano crashed, I finally had a chance to patronize an Apple Store. It was an excellent adventure.
Actually the experience started before I even got there, when I used the Apple website to schedule an appointment with an online “Concierge” for something called the “Genius Bar”. Four things struck me about the scheduling process.
- The fact I could schedule an appointment at all
- How simple the process was
- That they weren’t pumping me for personal data when I signed up
- They didn’t try to sell me anything
Genius.
When I arrived (early) the next day, the store was packed. Pandemonium. They had an “Apple Camp” or something going on, with kids dressed in bright green t-shirts learning how to use Apple products. Grinning patrons of all ages were fiddling around with Macs and iPhones. People I took to be regular customers walked in and out of the Genius Bar with their devices in tow – and smiles that seemed out of place at a repair depot. Despite the chaos, I was calmly greeted at the door by another one of these Concierge people, who assured me someone would soon escort me to the Genius Bar. This seemed odd. How would this someone identify me amid all these people?
Between the Concierge and the other Apple staffers who occasionally and politely asked me if I needed any help, the experience took on the air of checking into a luxury hotel. Ahead of schedule, an affable fellow named Adam came over and asked what the problem was. He had identified me by my shirt – the Concierge must have text messaged him. He fixed my nano in about 10 seconds and sent me on my way, with instructions on what to do should the problem recur.
Apple’s Brand Is Unbeatable
This experience was nothing like a PC experience or a Microsoft experience, precisely because there really is no such thing as a Microsoft retail experience. You might have a Best Buy experience or a Tiger Direct experience, but there is no Microsoft brand experience per se. For sales and to a great extent service, Microsoft is at the mercy of its dealers when it comes to customer satisfaction. Sound familiar? This approach nearly devastated the Big Three U.S. automakers.
Apple has a kickass brand because they own it. Their stores set the standard for the customer experience, and it is a high standard indeed. They’ve taken a page from the Japanese automakers’ book and turned painful tasks (purchasing and servicing a piece of technology) into something hassle-free and fun. I begin to see why Apple customers are so loyal. Apple treats us like … well, customers.

... And like This
Perhaps all this explains why Apple keeps a low profile in the media and social media. Why talk when your products say it all? Why evangelize when every customer does it for you? If testimonials are the most powerful form persuasion, Apple is sitting pretty for the next several generations. Those Apple Camp kids will be selling their kids on the brand 25 or 30 years from now.
(Do Apple Stores make an indelible branding impression? One company that apparently thinks so is Microsoft, who announced back in February they would open their own stores later this year. Indeed, Microsoft intends to locate their stores right next to Apple’s. This is a bold move, which might benefit Apple more than Microsoft. What do you think?)
Over to You
All this is probably common knowledge to any Apple fan, but from a PC guy’s perspective, these revelations make me even sorrier than ever to be locked into a permakludge computing environment. Microsoft may have the numbers, but Apple has the passion. Which do you think will win in the long run?
POSTSCRIPT – On July 21, 2009, Apple reported that its net profit jumped 15 percent, to $1.23 billion, or $1.35 a share, up from $1.07 billion, or $1.19 a share, in the quarter a year ago. These numbers represent the best non-holiday quarter revenue and earnings in Apple history.
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_b.png?x-id=d1aec1a6-ab60-4850-a115-22ca366b3a28)







Brad, what a fascinating experience, thanks for sharing it. Not trying to sell you anything seems to be a key part of the strategy, and letting the products speak for themselves.
They are also very good at hyping releases though, and generating feverish demand for new products. But maybe that’s also in part because the products are known to be good
PS thanks for teaching me kludge
Hi Joanna, Indeed Apple knows how to talk, but even their ad campaigns and such are minimalistic. “Think different” being a prime example. They are also brilliant at using images in favor of words – a topic you’ve taken an interest in lately.
As for kludge/kludgy, some people say kluge/klugey (i.e., clue-gee). I can’t make up my mind which I prefer.
Setting aside the technology issue (I’ve no interest in a flame war about whose OS is better), there is no doubt at all that Apple, from Jobs on down, has mastered brand management.
Regarding their marketing campaigns: I just finished In Pursuit of Elegance by Matthew May (recommended, by the way), and he pointed out that their marketing campaign for the first iPhone basically consisted of Job’s announcement a few months before it’s release. They let the buzz build itself.
Which raises the question: Would this have been nearly as successful if they hadn’t already built and managed their brand the way they have?
Brad,
As far as I see it, there are three different giants which stand out in today’s world of information technology:
First, there is Apple, an outstanding performer over recent years, invest their resources into making simple, sleek and easy to use and seem to have a sincere commitment to looking after the needs of their customers.
Then, there is Google, another phenomenal performer and a leader in innovation which again makes applications which are designed to meet user requirements and again feature a great deal of simplicity in use.
Lastly, in almost every way, there is Microsoft, which to have adopted a different customer perspective than either Apple or Google Whereas Apple see a customer as someone to be served, Microsoft seem to adopt a mindset of a customer as being something of a prisoner, someone whose needs need not be respected but who cannot be allowed to escape at all costs.
Maybe, just maybe, differing attitudes toward their customers go some way toward explaining why Apple and Google have been outstanding performers in recent years while poor old Microsoft seems to have been relegated on a seemingly permanent basis to a position of mediocrity ever since something called the internet became popular.
(Smile – I just love a chance to get stuck right in to Microsoft. Some criticisms of them are probably not entirely fair, but it sure seems to be fun to stick the boot right into them!)
Andrew, You’ve encapsulated the Big Three of Computing brilliantly – I wonder if there’s a post for you in this … something about the how to treat a customer perhaps. Thank you for sharing your ideas here, as always. Sure, everybody likes to take pot shots at the leader, and Google gets more than it’s fair share of criticism. Apple, somehow, seems immune.
Roy, Thank you for visiting & comments. The May book is now on my reading list. I’m not that familiar with the history of Apple and its marketing, but it seems there has always been a certain mystique around this company that is either the cause or result of their branding effectiveness. At this point, they have such a loyal following they can generate enormous word of mouth buzz at the lift of a finger. Companies without a powerful brand don’t have the luxury of being able to do that unless they get lucky or push just the right buttons.
Although you may be right about the Apple customer experience and all (you’re certainly right about the “Microsoft experience”), it still doesn’t make much difference to me. Apple has had its share of bad customer experiences too – it’s just that Apple customers seem more than willing to give ‘em a pass when it happens. In fact, it’s more like a religion – or a political leaning – than anything else.
Still, the market share is what really defines success, isn’t it? Has Apple’s market share grown, compared to Microsoft’s? That’s what measures success to me. Again, like those political “undecideds” who determine every election these days, what are the “OS undecideds” doing?
Great observation Brad. Apple was initially hurt by their “all under our roof” approach, when Microsoft was licensing their technology to every PC in the universe except Apple’s. Early in a technology’s life span, companies that keep their focus just on the technology excel. Some call this the “horizontal strategy.” But as technologies mature the bundlers, the ones who combine the technology with other aspect of a final product as Apple has done are usually the winners. (The “vertical strategy”) My guess is that Apple invested in stores not just to further enhance their value promise—we save you time and hassle—but for two other reasons. First, with the IPOD and IPHONE, they have more of a market than just loyal Apple Computer users. Retailers would never give Apple enough space to seize the larger market, so Apple went direct to consumer, not just through retail stores. Apple also did the stores I bet as a planned effort to go after the corporate market, where its computer share is weakest. For Apple to break into the business market, where PCs have dominated, you need a lot more users wanting indeed demanding Apple to offset the voice of the Information Technology Department that wants to standardize on PCs. IT wants PCs for cost reasons, for standardization and because IT people are more needed in a PC world. Slowly, companies are now allowing both Apple and Microsoft/PC computers. With cloud computing around the corner, I know who I’d bet on.
Best regards , KAY
Robert, I think you are right that Apple is like a religion (some of their online marketing pokes fun at that very thing). That’s an indication of how strong their brand is – wouldn’t every company want such a loyal customer base? I’m not sure I agree about market share being the ultimate measure of success. Profitability and sustainability are more important in my mind. I would rather have been Apple than GM yesterday, 10 years ago, 20 years ago. How about you? Lots of ways to look at it …
Speaking of which, thank you Kay for the historical context and keen insight. The iPod and iPhone have definitely brought Apple into the mainstream, and let’s face it – everybody loves playing around with both types of devices. A store is a natural. It’ll be interesting to see how Microsoft sets up their stores, given their product mix. What is Microsoft’s value promise?
Brad,
Fascinating observations and, by extension, lessons for all retailers. Sooner or later everyone will get the message is the product is only part of the total value perceived.
Bill
Bill, So true. From my days in packaging I recall how much the manufacturers were at the mercy of their distributors and independent reps for creating a product line’s brand. Unfortunately this means a product may have hundreds of “brands”; in other words, no clear idea of the brand emerges at all. A real problem that’s hard to combat.
Brad, I must confess that every time I read the word Apple I hear a symphony play in my head. The Mac is at the top of my wish list.
As Kay pointed out, it has been fascinating to watch Apple leverage what was initially viewed as a weakness into market distinction. Microsoft definitely has a market distinction as well. In my view if Microsoft attempts head to head combat they run the risk of stumbling and diluting their brand proposition. We have seen evidence in some of their recent marketing misses.
Now we just need to get you hooked up with a Macbook!
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
While Apple has made it’s share of mistakes, I have to agree with Roy that their brand management approach is phenomenal. From both a strategic and tactical experience they regularly seem to streamline powerful concepts in ways that let mere mortals get more out of their machines. And while the geniuses aren’t always, the odds tend to be better at the Apple store. What I’ve found fascinating is how significantly my experiences with ATT have been improving over the years since they partnered with Apple. I don’t know if we mac-addicts are more demanding or if it’s just been the natural improvements at ATT, but it reinforces my loyalty in general. (Of course ATT didn’t have that high of a bar to begin with.)
It’s very tempting … I think my next computer will be a Mac.
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
Believe I may have mentioned over lunch my movement from PC to Mac around retirement time. Turns out my employer did me a favor by not permitting purchase of the notebook PC I had been using! My wife’s old Mac was about to give up the ghost and I’m a notebook guy, so the refurbished MacBook Pro we purchased, complete with a Microsoft Student software package, was just what the doctor ordered. I’ve been able to live with the two small scratches on the case that knocked significant $ off the price! The only real challenge has been dumping my PC-bred right click habit and the rest has been pretty much smooth sailing. I’ve had a couple of very positive experiences with the Oak Brook store (likely the one you visited) and feel that Apple does an excellent job of creating among its customers very satisfied – and in many cases enthusiastic -marketers of the brand.
Karen, Apple runs circles around Microsoft in marketing … I think the MS store strategy is a mistake for them. We’ll see. I’m going with a Mac next time around – maybe we can team up and get a quantity discount!
Fred, ATT is working with Apple? That’s news to me … my love-hate relationship with ATT has been going on for decades. They are the most frustrating company ever to deal with on customer service issues, but their phone service ain’t half bad. What is Apple doing for/with them?
Brad, I think the iPhone has had that impact, but it could be my imagination. I came from Sprint which made ATT customer service look good by comparison. But even still, over the past few years things seem to be getting better. Or, maybe I’ve just given up hope. Hard to tell the difference sometimes.
Bill, Funny you mention the no-right-click … good to know it’s a breakable habit! It was indeed the Oak Brook store I visited, and, incidentally, the only place I saw at the mall that looked busy.
Fred, Maybe ATT has been using a siege strategy for customer service … wear them down over time. It worked for the Russians.
Made the switch years ago, while I was running a Windows software development company no less, and haven’t looked back since.
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
LOL. A few of my friends and family are devoted Mac users – they all seem to be lifers.
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
Oh, it’s much worse than that!
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
Apple knows that excellent customer service reinforces why those devoted to their products remain devoted for life, and they treat their employees just as well! (How many people get the Dell logo tattooed on their bodies? Not nearly as many as Apple addicts!). Apple knows that combining aesthetics, simplicity, and function will entice their customers, but treating those customers like family will keep them coming back! And keeping a sense of mystery about their releases (iPhone updates, new generation iPod shuffles, etc.) entices us even more.
However, I must disagree that they keep a “low profile” in the media. Their social media profile may be lower now than it was 20 years ago, but their computer, iPod, and iPhone television ad campaigns are almost as fun as the products themselves. Five years ago, most people did not own an iPod. If it hadn’t been for the dancing silhouettes on tv, I probably still wouldn’t have one!
Kim, It’s very cool you (and other Apple users) think of themselves as family. You’re absolutely right about the advertising; I guess I was thinking more about financial reporting and being active on Twitter, etc. Their advertising is some of the best around and has been since they started doing business.
Well, of course we all want to be the cool Mac guy in Apple’s commercials and not the dumpy PC nerd guy. The cool Mac guy is in movies and used to be on a TV show, but the PC nerd guy is a who-knows-who-he-is loser. Geez, man. We’re the Pepsi generation and it’s all about being cool.
Okay. I want an Apple.
Brad
Apple is the least marketing-orientated company (close tie with Google) that I know.
There is an arrogant edge to the culture which may appeal to a market segment; but only while they are winners.
They are extremely product driven. Their culture is a reflection of what Jobs wants (is) and when he leaves it will face huge challenges.
The cool Mac guy in the ads that some love are actually laughing at the 80% of the world who opted for PCs.
They do very good promotion though; and they really understand design. Let’s see how far that takes them.
Terry, Dennis – Good to hear from people who haven’t drunk the Apple Kool-Aid. Apple does seem to get the most out of their strengths – vision, marketing, design, etc. Certainly, Microsoft has the numbers in terms of market share, sales, etc. But I can’t help but feel they have too many customers who buy their products because it’s convenient or because there’s no perceived better option. As Kay mentioned, changes in technology that give consumers more choices could hurt MS.
Brad,
When I began to work with computers in the late 80ies, it was with Apple. I always thought I was technically challenged, and I liked the easy way of handling computers regarding hardware and software.
But when I thought about buying a laptop for myself in 2005 I decided to buy a pc laptop. The reasons: it was much much cheaper, and there’s a lot of freeware to use.
Regarding support and experiences in shops I must say that I had some pretty good ones with shops which sell pcs. People there were nice, non-arrogant and helpful.
Apple computers here in Germany are preferred by “creative people” – webdesigners, architects, and graphic designers. Some of them frown upon the “normal” pc user. This is an attitude I don’t like very much.
Hi Ulla, Here in the U.S., my sense is that Apple users fall into the same categories as in Germany, along with young people who grew up on Macs in school. I get the same anti-PC “vibes” from them, but it doesn’t bother me because I kind of agree with them, at least in terms of ease of use and functionality. The price issue you bring up has become a hot one here, probably because of the economy. I’ve read that even the younger crowd are buying PC simply because of the lower price. But Apple just reported better than expected Mac sales, so I don’t know what’s going on.
On the price thing, folks, think about it for a minute. Price vs. cost. With most PCs, beyond a couple of years, you tend to enter the “Gee, is it time to replace?” zone +, quite often, maintenance problems start to appear. Macs tend to take you out at least twice as long as a PC and the Apple folks take a great deal of pride in keeping you on your feet for an extended period. Once you come over from the dark side, there is little turning back! Whatever you can do on a PC, you likely can do just as well on a Mac – plus a great deal more.
How’s that for drinking the Kool-Aid?
PS – I don’t generally lean towards the White Sox in the Chicago baseball scene but hats off to Mark Buehrle for his perfect game today!
Bill, Thank you for that keen pricing insight – makes sense for cars as well. Even nicer, I must admit, is your mention of Mark Buehrle, who pitched a perfect game for the White Sox on July 23 – the first for the Sox since about 1922, which even I don’t remember.
What a day.
Guess I’m that dumpy PC guy sidling up to the Apple Kool-Aid for a drink. If your experience is anything to go by – and your endorsement means a lot to me – I’d be willing to come out from the dark side. Guess that will take me a long while though.
Hi Jan, It’s flattering that you put so much stock in my recommendations, but remember that my endorsement is based on sales, marketing, and branding performance & I have never used a Mac for more than half an hour at a time. I have, however, experienced hours of headaches with various MS products and trying to integrate them with open source products has been difficult.
Twitter Comment
Chat Catcher Test
My very first computer was an Apple IIc which I used to write my first novel. Eventually, I replaced that with a PC because I simply couldn’t afford a Mac.
I used PCs for the next 20 years and 10 novels. Last year, after a series of interesting events, I ended up with an iMac. I just replaced my aging Dell laptop with a MacBook Pro. I can’t imagine going back. I’m a SQL Server DBA for the day job, so PC’s don’t daunt me in any way. I’ve built my own in the past. But I have grown to hate the amount of work and money it takes to maintain and use a Windows system, even with Open Source.
I’m a die hard WordPerfect user (superior for novel writing) so I use Parallels on my Macs. Publishers these days are pretty much all electronic for manuscript editing, revisions, copy editing and page proofs, so I have Word for the Mac for those events. If WordPefect ran natively on the Mac (or if Word were less horrible for professional writing) I’d dump Windows entirely.
My experience in the Apple Store tracks with yours. The buying experience is no pressure. I had to have an iPhone repaired and there was no hard sell, no accusations that I’d done something underhanded. They just fixed it with a smile and I went on my way.
The Kool-Aid has been consumed.
Carolyn,
I’m curious: Why is WordPerfect superior to Word for novel writing?
Carolyn, Roy took the words right out of my mouth. Thank you for sharing your experience – few have the “crossover experience” you’ve had in both worlds.
Apple is so smart for providing superior customer care. We have an inherent dread of troubleshooting computers and mobile phones, much as we did about fixing cars until the Japanese figured out how to make auto repair an almost luxurious experience.
Ah, the lure of those shiny white cathedrals of consumerism . . . an essential landmark in any major town.
Mr goodcopybadcopy is an acolyte. Being more than averagely competent technically, he’s often fielding calls from friends about their broken computers. I couldn’t count the number of times I’ve heard the words “Well if they’d bought a Mac, they wouldn’t have this problem – they’d just be able to plug it in and go!”
I am trying desperately to remain sceptical. Walking into the Apple store with my Blackberry and ten-year-old mobile phone, I feel as smugly superior as Richard Dawkins at a Good Friday mass. That said, I’m not sure how much longer I can resist the tweet-on-the-go capabilities of the iPhone . . .
Clare, I bought a Blackberry recently (they didn’t scourge me for it at the Apple Store, even though I brandished it wildly as a defense mechanism). But an iPhone would have been a better buy. The web browsing capabilities of the Blackberry are Stone Age by comparison. If I want to achieve my goal of spending 25 hours a day on Twitter, the Blackberry will never do.
i’ve heard many good things about apple, their users swear by it, i just can’t give up my pc. i do have an ipod touch and i love it, but for the PC of course.
Hi Natural, There is a certain comfort level with a PC, but have you ever heard of anybody going from a PC to a Mac and then back to a PC? I’d hate to be the first one, tho. Thanks for stopping by and commenting!
Now we just need to get you hooked up with a Macbook!
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
It’s very tempting … I think my next computer will be a Mac.
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
Made the switch years ago, while I was running a Windows software development company no less, and haven’t looked back since.
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
LOL. A few of my friends and family are devoted Mac users – they all seem to be lifers.
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
Oh, it’s much worse than that!
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed