Image via WikipediaWe live in turbulent times. One advantage is there are lessons to be learned everywhere. What’s happening in U.S. politics these days is instructive from a marketing and branding point of view. Here’s my take, along with a little branding self-quiz.
Be consistent. Maverick one day, elder statesman the next … underdog, war hero, bridge builder, champion of the average Joe … who can keep track? Big danger in test marketing on a national stage. Is your brand clear and consistent? If not, people get confused. No sale.
Have a core message. Obama has one – change. Lame message in my opinion, but even a marginal core message is way better than none at all. People need a hook, something to latch on to. Do you have a core message? What is the essence of your brand?
Don’t imitate. McCain piggybacked on Obama’s theme of change. As a Republican, how can he avoid being perceived as Obama Lite? For real change, you have to be part of the opposing party. Is your brand unique? Or are you like the other guy, only cheaper?
Don’t be negative. McCain has gone hog wild with negative ads and, viola!, he’s sunk to a 14% deficit in the polls. The only prayer of making a negative message sell is if you yourself have a compelling brand. In the absence of that, a negative message is liable to have one of three outcomes. First, the voter will dig in and support the other candidate even more. Second, the voter will turn to a third candidate. Third, the voter will stay home. Works the same way in business. Does your brand communicate a positive message?
Don’t use gimmicks. I think Sarah Palin is awesome, but not credible as a candidate for this particular office. Once the novelty wears off, gimmicks rapidly lose their appeal. McCain’s VP choice was another case of imitation backfiring as well, as it undercut his ability to campaign against Obama’s inexperience. Does your brand offer real value, or is the allure smoke and mirrors? When the smoke clears, the customers will, too.
Ignite your base. Every candidate, every company, every product needs evangelists. It’s the hard core of die hard supporters who energize the public. McCain made a calculated risk in ignoring the Republican base in an attempt to woo swing voters. What’s the number one knock against McCain? “He just doesn’t get me excited.” Evangelists=excitement=sales. Do you have evangelists? Do you cultivate them? How many times a week do you say, thank you for your business?
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_b.png?x-id=c0fafa25-ec17-4475-8932-1e8c28d73f23)







Brad, most thought provoking post, thanks.
My only question – if McCain is pitching himself as maverick maybe the switches in message actually serve to reinforce that brand? That is, the brand is someone who isn’t packaged and marketed to death?
PS I think this is a great headline too
Joanna Youngs last blog post..What Would You Have Said?
Hi Joanna, No, I think McCain is switching around because he’s trying to be all things to all people or is all tactics and no strategy. The problem I see with your theory is that he seems so unnatural and uncomfortable, as though he’s not being himself.
Brad Shorrs last blog post..What Can John McCain Teach Us about Branding?
Well, at least McCain’s scattered campaign inspired a good post … because, seriously, I can’t remember the last time I saw a campaign make so many stupid mistakes! And honestly, my opinion of McCain has gone way down since the campaign started.
(Oh, and you’re invoking stringed instruments in the “Don’t be negative” section.)
(And, how weird, the CommentLuv didn’t show up on that post, and on this one, it’s about three posts old … how strange!)
–Debs last blog post..Business: It’s All in the Cards
Deb, Nice catch on the viola.
Comment Luv acts strangely sometimes, doesn’t it? McCain has gone steadily downhill, I agree. But to be fair, everything is working against him. Ah well, there’s always 2012.
Brad Shorrs last blog post..What Can John McCain Teach Us about Branding?
Brad, excellent branding points. Politics offers many lessons for marketers and writers. I view it like Fashion Week. The runway shows are over the top and the designs are not something you would really wear but they set the trend for design and color. The over the top is then adapted for the real world market. Politics is all about passionate speeches that get people to feel and do. We would not use the exact same techniques in marketing but a toned down version. I loved your analysis, and you presented great takeways!
Karen Swims last blog post..Blunders and other Wonders
Karen, Thank you – I like the fashion analogy. Where do you think this leaves us, over the top-wise? It seems like we’re hurtling toward a socialist state.
Brad Shorrs last blog post..What Can John McCain Teach Us about Branding?
First time here. Awesome post man!
Parths last blog post..The Push-up Workout Program for People Who Can’t Do Push-ups
Hi Parth, Thanks! Hope you come back.
Brad Shorrs last blog post..What Can John McCain Teach Us about Branding?
One aspect of political strategy which I am never comfortable with is the practice relying on winning via public attacks on the opposition, rather than positive, forward looking policies.
Rarely do you see successful companies launching public attacks on competitors as a high priority in corporate marketing effort. Just maybe, there might be a reason for this. Just maybe, it’s because that is not a successful strategy.
Instead, successful companies devote the majority of their marketing effort around communicating the benefits of their product or service offering. Maybe, just maybe, it’s because this is what works.
I don’t know why some tacticians believe that tactics which have been rejected by the corporate world will somehow produce effective results in politics.
Politicians should ask themsevles one question – who inspires confidence as a leader, the candidate selling a vision for the future (flaws and all), or the candidate who offers nothing but public attacks on the opposition?
Andrews last blog post..Socially Responsible Investing part 9: Does ethical investing compromise investment performance?
Andrew, I’m with you all the way on this. I really wonder what data political strategists see that leads them to think negativity is effective. Where I have seen companies go negative is on the street level, when a sales person “knocks the competition”. There are situations where that approach is very tempting, but I can’t remember ever seeing it work.
Brad Shorrs last blog post..The Best Marketing Advice that Came My Way